For anyone who’s been doing whole life carbon assessments over the past few years, the RICS guidance has been the main reference point. The 1st edition, published in 2017, gave the construction industry a common basis for measuring embodied carbon on buildings. It did a lot to get WLC assessments into the wider zeitgeist, although (as many of us found) it left quite a bit open to interpretation. Two consultants could model the same building and come out with some quite different numbers!
The 2nd edition was published in September 2023, with the most recent 3rd version having been in effect since July 2024, fully replacing the original. Having now used it on a fair number of projects, we thought it might be useful to share a few thoughts on what’s actually changed.
The most obvious of these changes is scope. The 1st edition only really focused on buildings. The 2nd edition covers the wider built environment as well as infrastructure and is set up to be used internationally rather than just in the UK. It’s also a much bigger document, at around 200 pages plus reporting templates, so it has taken some time getting used to and to digest fully.
Additionally, a couple of new life cycle modules have been introduced. A0 covers pre-construction activities like surveys and design work in offices. B8 covers user activities, such as commuting or vehicles using a road. Both are optional, and for most building projects I imagine they’ll stay that way given the difficulty in quantifying them. The more useful change is probably Module D being split into D1 (reuse and recycling of materials) and D2 (exported energy), which makes the benefits a bit clearer to read and present.
For us, though, the more important changes are probably the less headline-grabbing ones. The 2nd edition gives much clearer direction on areas that used to cause some debate, such as MEP services, grid decarbonisation, renewable energy and carbonation of concrete. It also brings in default allowances for things that were often left out at early stages, like demolition and repair. Any deviations from the standard now need to be recorded in the assessment too. None of this is especially exciting, but it should go a long way towards making assessments more consistent and comparable.
Early-stage results can come out a little higher than clients might be used to. This isn’t really because the buildings have got worse. It’s mainly because gaps that used to be left blank are now filled with sensible defaults. That’s probably a good thing and it gives a more realistic baseline to work from, with any reductions more likely to hold up as the design develops. Particularly also as the guidance now suggests the use of an uncertainty factor at earlier design stages, to account for potential margins of error or uncertainty with the design inputs.
That said, there are still areas where the construction industry have some work to do. MEP is an obvious one, still lacking clear and detailed guidance as to how to appropriately model at earlier stages. Though this is a problem actively being tackled by CIBSE. Façades are another, RICS points towards the CWCT methodology for these, which takes a bit more effort to apply properly. Module B5 refurbishment is also rarely looked at in any detail at concept stage. It’s probably fair to say the 2nd edition is more about filling in the missing gaps of the 1st edition methodology, though it represents a significant step forward.
If you’d like to talk through what it might mean for a scheme you’re working on, or how it ties in with GLA or Westminster Council planning requirements and BREEAM, please do get in touch. We’re always happy to have a chat.